You know, sometimes you just need cream for a cake and not frosting. My son and I had a big baking session one weekend recently and he made a basic box mix vanilla cake and he was wanting to fill it with jelly (jello) and cream. I didn’t have any cream and I’d made mock cream before so I thought I’d share how easy it is to make mock cream.


It’s nothing like that horrible white stuff you see in cake shops. Who knows what’s in that. I can remember years ago, the only cream bun you could get from the cake shop was one filled with real cream but not anymore. I can’t tell you the last time I had one because I know they use a fake white cream which I think is just whipped fat. For this recipe, I used the one that is Flo Bjelke-Petersen’s “Classic Country Collection”. It’s a great cookbook and one I use often for basic recipes. The only thing I didn’t have was caster sugar but I just used normal sugar and although a little grainy, it still tasted like cream.
It’s just a matter of beating the butter and sugar together until creamy, then add the vanilla and then adding the milk. You have to be careful to only gradually add the milk or else it won’t work.
I probably over beat my mock cream by a couple seconds because it’s not super smooth like normal whipped cream. You can see that it’s starting to split. But I used it anyway. It filled and topped the cake and it was super delicious.

I had some store bought icing flowers in the pantry so I topped the cake with those. It was delicious as an after lunch treat and everyone enjoyed it. My son was feeling super proud of his creation. It was filled with a port wine flavoured jelly, the mock cream and topped with the cream as well. (The indents in the side of the cake are from the baking paper we used to line the cake pan.) I’ll let him bake all the time if he can come up with creations like this.


How to make mock cream
Ingredients
- 2 tbs butter
- 4 tbs caster sugar
- 2 tbs milk
- 1/4 tsp vanilla
- 2 tbs water
Instructions
- Beat butter and sugar until light and creamy.
- Gradually add milk, beating all the time.
- Add 2 tbs water in a steady trickle, while beating.
- Add vanilla essence and beat until a creamy consistency.
Recipe Notes
Be careful not to over beat or else cream will split.
Please note, the above quantities are enough to either fill one layer or top a cake. You will need to double the recipe to do both or have a larger quantity to fill sweet buns or doughnuts, for example.
Adapted from Flo Bjelke Petersen's "Classic Country Collection" Cookbook



